Created on 11.16

What Should You Consider When Choosing a Case Packing System?

Selecting a case packing system goes beyond simply comparing speeds or carton sizes. The case packing system should be able to handle the products that will be on the line, deliver the desired output, and fit within the available space for production. Factors such as the weight, size, packaging form, and holding ability determine how the products are going to be loaded in the cases.
A case pattern is the formation of the individual items within a shipping case. The case patterns vary depending on the size, weight, and stability of the products in transit. Automation of the placement process may reduce repetition, but it is important to select a system based on the production requirements.
The product mix and line speed determine the extent of flexibility that we would want and the required output, respectively. Space considerations involve room for machine installation, product loading, carton supply, and operator access, among other things. Growth in production capacity may mean changes in product mix and output goals.

Summary Points

  • Make sure that the loading process is matched to the product shape, weight, and handling needs.
  • Look at carton dimensions and product packing before choosing the equipment.
  • Evaluate robot payload capacity, grippers, and real cycle times together.
  • Think about product changes and production needs ahead.
  • Integration with conveyors, palletizing, and other line equipment is essential.
Prior to equipment comparison, list all of the products and cases that the line should handle now and in the future.

What Case Packing System Type Is Suitable for Our Products?

There are different loading systems depending on the type of product. An easily breakable or oddly shaped product will require a different handling process compared to an even product, which will always remain in the same orientation.

Loading top and bottom

Top loading machines load products through open-top boxes from the top. The loading process and gripping system may vary according to the particular products used. They ensure proper placement of the product within the box depending on the required order.
In bottom-loading machines, the product is loaded from below as it is lifted to the open box. Bottom-loading machines may be ideal in situations where the product cannot be loaded easily from the top due to its design and stability.

Side-load, Wraparound, and Robotic Case Packing

The side-load machine uses the method of pushing or sliding the product horizontally into pre-formed cases. It is usually considered for products that have a consistent orientation and a constant flow through the line.
Wraparound packing entails wrapping a carton blank around a group of products. This system is capable of providing an effective compact packaging system for consistent products.
Even when choosing a small case packing system, there should be enough space for product in-feed, carton feed, and for operators.
Robotic case packing is more flexible because the products can be oriented in different ways, have different grippers, and be packed differently. The robot can use various end-of-arm tools for handling products with different sizes and weights. If product variety changes, a new gripper tool, product program, and case patterns might be needed.
A twin-axis robotic case packing system may be used in cases where there is a need for proper handling of items like bottles, bags, and others. The design to be used will depend on the weight, handling needs, size of the box, and production rate needed.
The automatic twin-axis case packing robots from Techflowbot are for use in applications where there are products such as bottles and bags.
Techflowbot twin-axis robotic case packing system for automated carton loading

When Is a High-Speed Case Packer Required?

A high-speed case packer is needed if the performance of the product loading and case packing rates is sufficient to match the production line's needs. Products per minute measure individual products, whereas cases per minute measure cases. They are not the same metrics, which is why the stated speed of the machine cannot represent the overall line speed.
A conventional product loading system might work well for the line with constant flow and orientation of products. The robotic loading system might be more effective when different orientations of products are possible or various product formats are to be loaded.
It should be noted that we need to estimate the time it takes to load empty cases, arrange the products, load them into cases, and unload the ready cases. If any of these operations is slower than other operations, then it will create a bottleneck, even if the robotic system works faster.
Let us compare loading systems by using actual products and carton formats instead of descriptions of equipment. We need to select the loading system based on product orientation and weight.

What Role Do Payload, Gripping Devices, and Cases Play in Productivity?

In a case-packing operation, the machine is required to do much more than load the products. The robot or machine has to lift not only the product but also the gripping devices and other devices that have been used in the loading process.

Inspect Robot Payload and Product Weight

By "robot payload," one means the total load carried by a robot under given operating conditions. This normally comprises the product, end effector, and any other equipment attached to the robotic arm.
When choosing robots for handling heavier products, robot payload becomes an important selection criterion. Nevertheless, choosing the robot solely based on its maximum payload is not always sufficient since reach, motion, cycle time, and location of the load will affect performance too.
For instance, when it comes to Techflowbot's TCR-20 two-axis case packing robot, its maximum payload is 40 kg, and its maximum pack rate is 20 cycles per minute. The values can serve as a reference point when considering applications with heavier products since performance actually depends on the arrangement of products, gripper, and operating conditions.
The selected robot should be capable of carrying the full load under the required motion and output conditions.

Choose gripping tools based on the product attributes

The end-of-arm tooling influences the way the robot will grab and release the products. There can be various ways of gripping depending on the product.
  • Vacuum cups: For those products and surfaces of packaging where vacuum gripping is possible and reliable.
  • Mechanical gripper: For those rigid products that can be safely physically grabbed.
  • Custom gripping tools: If the shape or size of the product makes it necessary.
  • Multipick tooling: In case several products can be picked at once, and their position and weight allow doing so.
It is recommended to test the gripping tool with real products, not just the samples, which might not accurately represent the final product. The surface material, the shape of the product, its weight distribution, and packaging condition might influence gripping performance.

Check carton size and packing configuration

The carton has to ensure there is enough space for the product and, at the same time, have a stable configuration when in transit. The size of the product, case size, clearance, and packing configuration have to be confirmed together.
There might be a configuration suitable for a certain product configuration but not another. If the product size or quantity changes, then there will be a requirement to change the configuration or robot program.
Before proceeding to confirm the design, you should check the configuration using the actual product and carton.

How Should the Production Rate and Changeover Be Evaluated?

The rated speed of a particular machine is not the only criterion for selecting it. The production rate is influenced by the product feed, gripping, robot motion, carton availability, and coordination among machines.

Comparison of cycle time with required output rate

First, measure the required number of products and completed cases to be produced per minute. After that, find out if the proposed solution is able to satisfy this requirement with the specified operating conditions.
In the case of robotized case packing, cycle time is defined by:
  • Number of products taken up per cycle
  • Product weight and grip method
  • Distance from picking and loading stations
  • Product orientation requirements
  • Dimensions of the carton and its packing scheme
A multi-product robot will decrease the number of separate movements, but the load should stay within the allowed payload of the robot, and the gripper should remain stable.

Prepare for product variation and changeover

It might be necessary to vary products by size, packaging, or case formation. It would, therefore, make sense for the system to be assessed on its ease of adapting to these differences.
While some modifications might entail simply switching to another product program, other variations might call for a change in the gripper tools, conveyor location, or case feeders.
As you evaluate different options, find out from manufacturers what types of variations will require manual intervention or special tooling for different products.

How Does Case Packing Integrate into the Whole Assembly Line?

The case packing step can simply be a single step in the end-of-line operation. Following the placing of the goods in boxes, there may still be a need to transport, arrange, palletize, and move the cases to storage or shipping locations.
If all of these steps are designed independently, disparity in the production rate can lead to bottlenecks between the machines. For instance, the case packing equipment may produce cartons faster than the palletizing machine is able to handle.

Think about the conveyor and equipment interface

When deciding which case packing line to choose, evaluate the location and speed of operation of upstream and downstream equipment.
Factors to consider are
  • Feed of products and product positioning prior to case packing
  • Supply of empty cartons and output of finished cases
  • Location and orientation of conveyors and locations for conveyor transfer
  • Space available for robot movement and maintenance
  • Integration between case packing and downstream palletizing processes
All of these will help you decide how well the equipment will integrate into the production process.

Palletizing down the line

After the case packing stage, there is usually a need to organize cartons in a specific pallet pattern. This is determined by the size and weight of cartons and their stability, as well as transportation needs.
For high-handling production lines, palletizing can be an option along with case packing. Combining both stages will facilitate the organization of cartons and prevent repetitive handling at the end of the line.
Techflowbot also offers robotic palletizing systems for end-of-line operations. Evaluating the case packing and palletizing process can assist in planning an organized packaging process.
Industrial robots are used across a range of manufacturing applications, including material handling, packaging, and palletizing. The International Federation of Robotics provides further information about industrial robots and their applications in manufacturing.
Integrated robotic case packing and palletizing system with conveyor handling

What Questions Should We Ask of the Equipment Manufacturer When Purchasing?

Since two quotes for packaging equipment may describe quite different solutions, we should compare their contents before analyzing the quoted cost. Case packing equipment prices depend on such factors as product type, type of cartons used, required speed, robot configuration, tooling, system integration, and installation requirements.
When evaluating potential suppliers, analyze their ability to understand your production process and configure equipment according to it.
Before requesting a quote from manufacturers, provide them with the following information:
  • Samples and dimensions of products to be packed; weight of products
  • Cartons used; case specifications
  • Required output and working hours
  • Variety of products and changeover requirements
  • Existing line layout and available floor space
  • Information about upstream and downstream equipment
  • Utility requirements
  • Installation and commissioning needs
  • Training and support requirements
It may also be worth asking the manufacturer if they can make a test of the actual products and cartons before designing the equipment.
Use the same requirements for all manufacturers. Evaluating products, cartons, output, and integration scope by all suppliers allows you to compare their proposals easily.

Conclusion

The appropriate case packing solution would be based on the type of products, the types of cartons to be used, the necessary output, and the production line environment. Factors such as payload capacity, gripper options, cycle time, and case patterns will determine the suitability of the machines to the particular application.
Robotic case packing is an option that may be considered by those manufacturing different products or carrying heavy payloads. Considering case packing with conveyors and palletizing in the production line design could help optimize material flow in the production line.
Prior to requesting a proposal, it is best to have ready product samples, the carton type, the target output, and the line layout. This would give the equipment manufacturers a good head start in evaluating the application and determining the proper automation solution.

Contact

Leave your information and we will contact you.

Contact

E-mail: info@techflowbot.com

Tel: +86 18616129085

Add: 99 Shenmei Road, Pudong New District, Shanghai